Fishing In

Shrewsbury, Pennsylvania

With FishAngler you can discover the best fishing spots in Shrewsbury. Check out the top fish species being caught and learn what baits are the most successful. Get detailed information on when and where the fish are biting in Shrewsbury and get valuable tips to increase your fishing success.
39.762046, -76.69446

Recent Catches In Shrewsbury, Pennsylvania

Cameron Mallow At Unnamed / Magnolia Dr Pond

2024-06-27
 • 
York County, Pennsylvania

My new PB

Largemouth black bass
3 lb
1
12 likes • 2 comments

Melissa DiMartino At New Freedom Pond

2023-08-19
 • 
York County, Pennsylvania

Large mouth at a private pond

1 lb 5 oz
8 likes

Ben Beck

2022-09-05
 • 
York County, Pennsylvania

Nice bluegills tonight

Bluegill
10 likes

Ben Beck

2022-09-05
 • 
York County, Pennsylvania

Quite a few bass too, heres a few

10 likes

Tim Black At South Branch Codorus Creek

2021-04-22
 • 
York County, Pennsylvania

The fish commission finally stocked the creek by my work. I caught my first rainbow from the hole I fish. That gives me the trout triple from the same hole. Brown,brook, and rainbow.

Rainbow trout
31 likes • 4 comments

Tim Black At South Branch Codorus Creek

2021-04-14
 • 
York County, Pennsylvania

This is my PB wild Brown trout. Last Friday I caught one that was around the same length it did not have the weight. Every time I catch one it is on the same type of minnow I catch in the stream in my minnow trap. I can’t get more then one or two of these minnows a week. They have red under there front fin and they look exactly like a fathead with out the fathead. The one I used was bigger then I thought would work 2” atleast. I couldn’t be more happy to have these beautiful trout out back of where I work.

Brown trout
1
48 likes • 3 comments

Tim Black At South Branch Codorus Creek

2021-04-13
 • 
York County, Pennsylvania

Caught this little guy on my lunch break. He kept stealing my worm. Finally I caught him in the act and was happy to see it was a wild brown trout. Same hole as I caught the bigger in picture last Friday.

Brown trout
1
35 likes • 2 comments

Tim Black

2021-04-09
 • 
York County, Pennsylvania

Is this a wild of stocked brown 15 6/8 is how long and he is skinny. I know they stock below where I was fishing. Those trout were brook and rainbow I caught down stream 1/2 mile or more. This is a brown that is really long and skinny. I let him go. From last Saturday until today is the best week I have had fishing in fresh water. I have caught between 40-70 trout( let the kids reel in the trout Saturday. . I went out to the creek on my lunch break. Caught the same brown 2x with in 30 seconds of throwing him back he hit the minnow first alive. Then he ate him dead. I’m not sure if it’s a wild or stocked. I will never forgot that trout. I saw him in there Wednesday he wouldn’t bite. I saw one more that is bigger. I added a brown that is definitely wild. Caught in the same hole as the bigger one.

Brown trout
2
42 likes • 6 comments
Want to see more catches in
Shrewsbury, Pennsylvania
Blue background image
App image
Want to know more about fishing in or around
Shrewsbury?
Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all the intel you need to catch more fish!
Rating App Reviews