Fishing At

Windmill Pay Lake

No Rating (0)

10 Catches

Windmill Pay Lake is located in Washington, Ohio. Download FishAngler to find the best places to fish at Windmill Pay Lake. Get local fishing reports with detailed catch information, weather conditions, top baits and more.

Access & Amenities

39.390381, -84.045979

Explore Full Map

Recent Catches At Windmill Pay Lake

All flatheads. First flatheads this year. Heaviest was 17.

Species Flathead catfish

Weight 12 lb

22 likes

Blue Cat using goldfish

Species Blue catfish

Weight 17 lb 6 oz

17 likes • 1 comment

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Onem the other night 9 all together 3 20s

4 likes

21 flatty from the other night

Weight 21 lb 10 oz

19 likes • 1 comment

Nice day, caught 9 all together. This was 24lbs

Weight 24 lb 2 oz

26 likes • 1 comment

Blue

Weight 37 lb 10 oz

25 likes • 5 comments

The only picture I took of 7 fish today. 16lbs flathead

21 likes • 1 comment

First time at the mill!

Species Flathead catfish

Weight 15 lb 3 oz

7 likes

Get Ready

To Fish

with the best fishing app on the planet

Download The App

Most Caught Fish Species At Windmill Pay Lake

Flathead catfish

Popular Fishing Spots Near Windmill Pay Lake

38.6 mi away • Preble County, Ohio

Rocky Fork Lake

30.8 mi away • Highland County, Ohio

Unnamed / Anthony Ln - Pond

15.7 mi away • Franklin, Ohio

Great Miami River

14.1 mi away • Montgomery County, Ohio

11.7 mi away • Warren County, Ohio

Great Miami River

27.1 mi away • Butler County, Ohio

Little Miami River

0.9 mi away • Warren County, Ohio

Crains Run Nature Park Pond

19.1 mi away • Miami, Ohio

Blue background image

App image

Want to know more about fishing at

Windmill Pay Lake?

Download the FishAngler app to get access to advanced fishing maps, local fishing reports & forecasts. Join millions of anglers and get all the intel you need to catch more fish!